Possible to show watched items on home screen under recently added?

We have a few family members that watch the same TV Shows at different times. When the first one of us watches the latest ep it disappears from the home screens recently watched. Is it possible to keep it there? Like always show watched files in recently added on the home screen.

I know you can still click recently added and see it in the recently added section but that’s tedious and I’d like to stick to the functionality on the home screen.