Trakt.tv: Progress menu displays shows I have never watched

I am using Trakt.tv with Kodi to make finding and watching shows a little bit easier. However, I am having a problem with My TV Shows –> Progress feature. I reached out to Trak.tv and they suggested it is most likely an issue with Kodi.

On Trakt’s website, my watch history appear to be correct. When I launch Kodi and go to My TV Shows –> Progress, it shows many shows that I have never watched. Has this happened to anyone else? Do you know if there any way to reset this so that trakt.tv will sync properly? It’s a bit aggravating to traverse through 20-30 shows I have never watched to find the ones that I am.

Thank you!